The Midnight Bayonets: Tragedy at the Hancock House

A few miles south of Salem, New Jersey, tucked away from the hum of modern highways, lies the quiet hamlet of Hancock’s Bridge. In this small village stands one of the most striking examples of colonial architecture in America: a patterned-brick house that has stood for over 290 years. But while its exterior is a masterpiece of Quaker craftsmanship, its interior holds the memory of one of the most chilling atrocities of the American Revolution.

---

A Masterpiece in Patterned Brick

The landscape of Salem County is famous for its “patterned brick” houses—a traditional English Quaker building method where masons used fire-glazed blue bricks to create intricate designs. The Hancock House, built in 1734 by William and Sarah Hancock, is a premier example of this art.

• Flemish Bond: The house features a checkerboard design created by alternating red “stretchers” and blue-glazed “headers.”
• The Gable End: On the western wall, the masons used blue bricks to weave a permanent signature into the structure: the initials [HWS] for William and Sarah and the date 1734.
• Wistarburg Glass: The windows were originally fitted with glass from the nearby Wistarburgh Glass Works, America’s first successful glass factory.

The Bridge and the Judge

The house sits on land purchased from Quaker founder John Fenwick in 1675. By 1708, the Hancocks had built a bridge over Alloways Creek, creating a vital link between Salem and Greenwich. By the mid-1700s, the Hancocks were among the wealthiest families in the colony. William Hancock II, who inherited the house in 1762, was a pacifist Quaker who served as a Judge of the County Court and remained a loyal subject of the Crown.

---

The Massacre: March 21, 1778

By 1778, the Revolutionary War had turned New Jersey into a desperate foraging ground. British troops in Philadelphia were starving and sought to plunder the fertile farms of Salem County. The local New Jersey militia, determined to protect their supplies, used the Hancock House as a strategic barracks to guard the bridge.

Frustrated by militia resistance, British Colonel Charles Mawhood issued a terrifying mandate to his troops: “Go—spare no one—put all to death—give no quarters.”

• The Surprise Attack: Under the cover of darkness, Major John Graves Simcoe and 300 British troops—guided by local Loyalists—crept through the marshes to avoid detection.
• No Shots Fired: At 5:00 AM on March 21, the British burst through the front and rear doors of the Hancock House. In the darkness and confusion, they bayoneted every man inside.
• A Double Tragedy: Among the victims was Judge William Hancock himself. He had unexpectedly returned home that evening to sleep in his own bed, only to be mortally wounded by the very British soldiers he remained loyal to. He died several days later.

---

The Swedish Plank Cabin

Located on the grounds just east of the mansion is a rare architectural survivor: the Swedish Plank Cabin. This one-room structure, dating back to at least 1701, is a rare example of hand-hewn white cedar plank construction used by early Swedish settlers in New Jersey. Known as a stuga (room inside), the cabin features four-inch-thick planks and dovetailed corners—a precursor to the classic American log cabin.

If You Visit

The Hancock House is a New Jersey State Historic Site and serves as a somber memorial to the men who perished there.

• Location: 3 Front St, Hancock’s Bridge, NJ 08038.
• The Museum: The house is furnished to reflect the 18th century, with exhibits detailing the brick-making process and the events of the massacre.
• The Architecture: Look closely at the exterior bricks to find the etched initials of the original 1734 brick-makers, like “SH” and “EM.”
• The Cabin: Step inside the Swedish Plank Cabin to see the traditional dovetailed construction and seventeenth-century building techniques.

---

For More Information:

• The Friends of the Hancock House (www.hancockhouse.org)